Yesterday The New York Times article, “We Have Met the Enemy and He Is PowerPoint” spurred hundreds of comments in a matter of hours on NYTimes.com. It was the most emailed article all day.
I couldn’t help myself and posted this comment:
I am by no means a PowerPoint fan. In fact, I think PowerPoint really lacks the basic presentation toolkit. However, a comment, such as “PowerPoint makes us stupid”—mentioned in this article—is an irresponsible statement. It is the same excuse as “My dog ate my homework.”
The key to a successful presentation is to tell a good story. Yes, PowerPoint definitely ranks the lowest in my toolbox. However, I have seen great presentations using PowerPoint. We don’t expect a word processor to choose our vocabulary or organize our thoughts. Why should we depend on a presentation software program to do the graphic thinking for us?
People who have read my new book, The Wall Street Journal Guide to Information Graphics, always want to know the software I used. Again, it’s not about the software. It’s about the analytical thinking and storytelling. It’s about optimizing each tool to bring out the essence of the information and illuminate the story.
Killing PowerPoint won’t give you a better presentation. Telling a good story will.
The real issue is that while everyone has to take writing courses, people aren’t even offered a Presentation 101 course—either in school or on the job. It’s easy to blame the software when things don’t come off well.
The biggest presentation mistake people make is to treat their slides, speaker’s notes and handouts as the same document. The slides should be an engaging visual journey for your audience. The speaker’s notes are at the podium to jog your memory in case you go blank during the talk—NOT to read from. The handouts should be highlights and takeaways, or additional reading materials.
Instead, in 99 percent of today’s presentations the speakers read from their own slides, set at 20 point size type or smaller (similar to a book set at 8 point type). The audience feels like they are taking an eye exam.
To illustrate what I’m talking about, I’ll use my comments on The New York Times article to show how to build a memorable slide from bulleted text. To prove my point I am going to use PowerPoint to do it.
A typical slide with bulleted text

Improved: one point per slide

High visual, high impact

Speaker’s notes and voice over with this last slide would be: I am by no means a PowerPoint fan. In fact, I think PowerPoint really lacks the basic presentation toolkit. However, a comment, such as “PowerPoint makes us stupid” mentioned in this article is an irresponsible statement. It is the same excuse as “My dog ate my homework.”
Don’t get me wrong, PowerPoint can be a clumsy and ineffective tool. But at the end of the day, it is your visual and storytelling skills that make for a winning presentation.
Dona Wong is a Strategy Director of Information Design for Siegel+Gale’s New York office.
