Well-intentioned but misguided
Food marketers have latched onto the idea that having only a few ingredients will make their products appealing to consumers “Marketers such as Starbucks discover that simple sells,” USA Today, October 28, 2009). This is as bad as using readability formulas to judge whether a document is understandable.
What consumers really crave is a short list of familiar, wholesome ingredients. We respond to the idea of just five ingredients because we assume that those five won’t be dehydrated potato flakes, monosodium glutamate, whey solids, artificial coloring and artificial flavoring.
A shorter list may be quicker to read and therefore more transparent, but transparency itself is not the goal—we need to focus on what is revealed behind the curtain. To know all is definitely not to forgive all.